How Should Errors in Normative Claims be Pointed Out?

Morishima, Atsuki

Proceedings of International Seminar 2021 : Coping with the “New Normal” and the Promotion of International Exchange, 2022, 44-49

アクセス数:138件（2025-06-02 19:22 集計）

固定URL: https://doi.org/10.18910/89122

閲覧可能ファイル 

ファイル フォーマット 利用条件 サイズ 閲覧回数 利用開始日 説明 information
pis_2021_044 pdf なし 992 KB 53 2022.09.12  

論文情報

ファイル出力 EndNote Basic出力 Mendeley出力

タイトル
How Should Errors in Normative Claims be Pointed Out?
著者
著者名
Morishima, Atsuki
抄録
The purpose of this paper is to answer the question: how should errors in normative claims be pointed out? Against this question, this paper demonstrates the ideal model of the person who points out the errors in normative claims. The first chapter analyzes “normative claims” themselves, based on the theory of “discourse ethics” proposed by Habermas. This chapter indicates that the validity of normative claims emerges only through a consensus in “discourse.” Next, the second chapter focuses on the “discourse” and analyzes this deeper structure. Based on this analysis, consequently, the model of the opponent who points out errors is demonstrated. The model is as follows: An opponent must, initially, admit the validity of a proponent’s claim, at least from the perspective of the “background discourse” through which the claim can be valid.
出版者
International Affairs Office, School of Letters/Graduate School of Humanities, Osaka University
収録物名
Proceedings of International Seminar 2021 : Coping with the “New Normal” and the Promotion of International Exchange
ページ
44-49
刊行年月
2022-07
言語
英語
ハンドルURL
https://hdl.handle.net/11094/89122
DOI
https://doi.org/10.18910/89122
関連情報 (isIdenticalTo)
ISBN
978-4-908326-10-3
アクセス権
open access
出版タイプ
Version of Record
カテゴリ
会議発表論文 Conference Paper
Coping with the “New Normal” and the Promotion of International Exchange