紀要論文

紀要論文

text

阪大音楽学報. 2020, 16・17, p. 1-13

日本語

text

2020-09-30

On the basis of the ideology of authenticity, this paper discusses the characteristics of Early music performances and how they are defined. The author focuses on the articles of Nikolaus Harnoncourt and Gutav Leonhardt's Bach Church Cantata Recordings（1971‒1989）, written by Richard Taruskin between 1982 and 1994. Taruskin's efforts to transform the debates on authenticity and Early music performance gradually gained momentum in the 1960s. His critical articles and reviews were summarized in Text and Act（1995）, adding postscripts in 1994. In mid-twentieth century aesthetics, in the context of historicism, European authenticists have discussed and contrasted romantic style and Early music performances. “Theory” and “practice” had not been examined as different terms of ideology in the 1970s. Some authors have theoretical explored historically informed performance（HIP; for example, Nick Wilson studied the relation between HIP and “the authenticity business” during the 1970s and 1980s in Britain and Lydia Goehr and Peter Kivy studied the issue of HIP as a disciplining of performance practice, subjecting it to a text-based musicology）. In contrast, Taruskin approached score as “text,” considering it on the basis of the ideology of theory. Because Taruskin thought that the authenticity of musical work is based on the modern attitudes of the performers who show how they are going to realize the essence of the work, he argued that authenticity in performance cannot be evaluated from merely a viewpoint of historical accuracy. Therefore, Taruskin attempted not to understand Early music performance from the viewpoint of historicity but rather to define it assuming that it contained aspects of modernity. Thus, Taruskin's critique of authenticity triggered arguments between European and US scholars from the 1980s onward.

10.18910/98475

98475

リチャード・タラスキンのオーセンティシティー論を再考する

杉山, 恵梨

大阪大学文学部・大学院文学研究科音楽学研究室

日本語

2020-09-30

阪大音楽学報

16・17

1

13

https://hdl.handle.net/11094/98475

10.18910/98475

https://doi.org/10.18910/98475