西垣内・西山論争を読み解く : 何が生産的議論を阻害するのか

山泉, 実

大阪大学大学院人文学研究科紀要, 2025, 2, 185-216

Number of Access:190（2025-07-18 14:22 Counts）

Identifier to cite or link to this item: https://doi.org/10.18910/100807

Link to primary information 

File Format Terms of use Size Views Date.Available Description information
mgsh002_185 pdf None 2.87 MB 104 2025.04.04  

Item Information

Output File Export EndNote Basic Export Mendeley

Title
西垣内・西山論争を読み解く : 何が生産的議論を阻害するのか
Untangling the Debate between Dr. Nishigauchi and Dr. Nishiyama : Focusing on Dr. Nishigauchi’s (Mis)interpretation of the Notions of Unsaturated Nouns and Variable Noun Phrases
ニシガウチ　ニシヤマ　ロンソウ　ヲ　ヨミトク　ナニガ　セイサンテキ　ギロン　ヲ　ソガイ　スルノカ
Creator
NRID
1000080592336 1000080592336
researchmap permalink
yamaizumiminoru yamaizumiminoru
CreatorName
山泉, 実 ; ヤマイズミ, ミノル
Subject
論争
非飽和名詞
変項名詞句
指定文
潜伏疑問文
Abstract
Taisuke Nishigauchi and Yuji Nishiyama have engaged in a prolonged debate across various linguistic platforms in Japan, marked by numerous misunderstandings and inconsistencies that have hindered productive discourse. This paper aims to clarify these issues, providing readers with a clearer understanding and framework to evaluate the debate objectively. Rather than aligning with either side, or introducing a third perspective, I seek to identify and elucidate the key discrepancies between the two scholars to foster more fruitful future discussions. The debate encompasses topics such as specificational sentences, concealed questions, and the theoretical constructs used to analyze these phenomena. This paper specifically examines Nishigauchi’s interpretation―or misinterpretation―of Nishiyama’s concepts of unsaturated nouns and variable noun phrases, exploring the origins of these misunderstandings. Through this analysis, I aim to highlight the factors that contribute to unproductive scholarly debates, both in linguistics and academia at large.
Publisher
大阪大学大学院人文学研究科
Graduate School of Humanities, Osaka University
Source Title
大阪大学大学院人文学研究科紀要
Memoirs of the Graduate School of Humanities, Osaka University
Volume (Issue)
2
Page
185-216
Date of Issued
2025-03
Language
Japanese
Handle URL
https://hdl.handle.net/11094/100807
DOI
https://doi.org/10.18910/100807
PISSN
27589102
NCID
AB00040926
Access Rights
open access
oaire:version
Version of Record
Category
紀要論文 Departmental Bulletin Paper
Memoirs of the Graduate School of Humanities, Osaka University / Vol.2